Insurers encourage business interruption policy claims after High Court defeat

An Australian insurance group has launched an advertising campaign encouraging pandemic affected business owners to lodge a claim, but warn that the “vast majority” of cases will be held up pending a decision in the Federal Court.

The High Court has rejected an application by the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) to appeal a test case decision which sought to clarify whether COVID-19 was excluded from extra cover for infectious diseases in a business interruption policy.

In this first test case, insurers asserted that policies which reference the Quarantine Act (which was repealed and replaced in 2015) should instead be interpreted as the now referenced Biosecurity Act. In doing so, policy holders would need to claim against a listed human disease. Where the policy refers to an exclusion clause which notes that the list of diseases is subject to “subsequent amendments” insurers argued that these referred to future amendments.

The five judges of the NSW Court of Appeal unanimously found in favour of policy holders and determined that as COVID-19 did not fall within the scope of the exclusion clause, insurer’s liability extended to pandemic related business interruption cover.

The ICA argued against such findings in their special leave application to the High Court and contested that a mistake had been made.

Whilst the High Court’s rejection of the ICA’s application is an immense blow to the Australian insurance industry, it provides insureds with the long-awaited certainty over whether they can rely on the Quarantine Act exclusion and deny liability in policies written in the same terms as the first test case.

The ICA has responded to their defeat by encouraging small businesses to lodge their business interruption cover claims but note that they await further clarification from a second test case before a “vast majority” of claims can be finalised.

The second test case commenced by insurers in February 2021 intends to clarify the meaning of policy wordings for the definition of a disease, proximity of an outbreak to a business and prevention of access to premises due to government mandate. Whilst the knockback experienced in the first test case has left insurers “disappointed”, the ICS in their statement on special leave application has “committed to applying the decisions of both test cases in an efficient, transparent, and consistent way when assessing claims”.

What does this mean for policy holders?

The end of financial year provides significant challenges in the lodgement of a business interruption claim. We encourage small and medium sized businesses to seek an urgent assessment of their policy and start gathering evidence now to calculate losses sustained from the COVID-19 pandemic before the second test case is finalised.

Elit Lawyers by McGirr & Snell is one of the only law firms who can act for insurance policy holders (businesses and individuals) against major insurers. Our senior litigation team has a combined 60 years experience acting on behalf of major insurers and know how they work. To have your policy reviewed by our team, contact Danielle Snell and Robert McGirr.

Share
Email
Print

Get in touch

With us personally, it is just one more way we’re different.

Danielle Snell

CO-FOUNDER AND MANAGING PARTNER

.

Robert McGirr

CO-FOUNDER AND PARTNER

.

"

"The best of the best plaintiff lawyers against insurance companies. We had a very tough and complex case and Danielle and her team settled with the insurance company for an optimal outcome."

Insurance Policy Holder

Home owner

The best of the best plaintiff lawyers team against insurance companies.

We had a very tough and complex case against insurance company that we lost our home and contents.  After disappointing and frustrating process from another law firm and firing them we found Danielle Snell and her team.

They are very dedicated, knowledgeable, passionate and possess great communication skills.  We couldn’t ask for more and settled with a optimal outcome.

"

"It’s great to be able to confidently refer clients to someone who can help and support them, and to feel that they are receiving the best service."

Senior Adviser

Financial Planner

We are so glad to have you in our referral channel.

It’s great to be able to confidently refer clients to someone who can help and support them, and to feel that they are receiving the best service.

"

"This was a “David v Goliath” fight as our dispute was with a large global corporation. The attention, compassion and guidance that Danielle and the team showed us was absolutely incredible."

CEO & Founder

National mental-health support organisation

We recently instructed Danielle from Elit Lawyers by McGirr & Snell to help with a legal dispute. As a small purpose led business, this was a “David v Goliath” fight as our dispute was with a large global corporation. This dispute was during a very emotional time as we were in the middle of a global pandemic, Melbourne’s sixth lockdown, homeschooling and no childcare – all while trying to keep our small business alive.

The attention, compassion and guidance that Danielle and the team showed us was absolutely incredible. I have 10 years legal experience myself and even with that, I was reluctant to litigate, especially during such a difficult time. However Danielle always gave us confidence in knowing that she was in our corner and always working for our best interests, so my reluctance was quickly appeased.

Today I am pleased to share that David defeated Goliath and we could not be more thrilled with the result we received thanks to Danielle and the team from Elit Lawyers. Danielle not only saved our company, but ensured that we could continue doing the good work we were previously and helping improve the lives and mental health of mothers across Australia.

I could not recommend Danielle and the team from Elit Lawyers more highly. I am *hoping* that I will never need their services again, but feel very reassured knowing they are there and always in my corner.

Thank you Danielle and team.

"

"Elit negotiated a settlement which saw all proceedings against my company dismissed, with no order as to costs."

Owner and Managing Director

Major Transport Company

I was recently introduced to Elit Lawyers by McGirr & Snell by my former lawyers after they were required to cease acting for me due to a conflict of interest. The stakes were high as my company was exposed to multiple court proceedings. Elit Lawyers by McGirr & Snell impressed me so much. They went that extra mile and were able to negotiate a settlement which saw all proceedings against my company dismissed, with no order as to costs. I can’t thank Elit enough.

"

"Danielle is a well-known and respected lawyer who knows how to handle difficult and intensive litigation."

Queens Counsel, Devers List

Victorian Bar

Danielle Snell is a very intelligent and impressive lawyer whom I have worked with in my role as senior counsel on various litigation matters.  She is a well-known and respected lawyer who knows how to handle difficult and intensive litigation.  Danielle combines a deep knowledge of the law across many practice areas with a practical approach to litigation, and is authentic and charismatic in her dealings with others.

"

"Danielle and Robert demonstrate outstanding expertise and approach all matters methodically with a clear and practical focus..."

Chief Operations Officer

Peak industry body for fire protection

As Chief Operating Officer it is extremely important to work with lawyers who are easily accessible, honest and trustworthy.  We have briefed Elit Lawyers by McGirr and Snell across various legal disciplines and now use them as our “go to” solicitors.  Danielle and Robert demonstrate outstanding expertise and approach all matters methodically with a clear and practical focus on achieving the best possible result.

Previous
Next

Can't find what you're looking for?